|
Why
the slave museum is a good idea
"This
Old South, in short, was a society beset by the specters
of defeat, of shame, of guilt - a society driven by
the need to bolster its morale, to nerve its arm against
waxing odds, to justify itself in its own eyes and in
those of the world."
My favorite explanation of things Southern comes from
a 1940 volume called "The Mind of the South"
by a Carolina newspaperman named W.J. Cash who wrote
the above lines. If you want to get decent insights
into what has moved minds in this part of the country
- this enormously troubling and compelling history of
the South - Cash's work is for you.
As with the history of any region, though, there is
revisionism. Sometimes it's good, and sometimes it is
bad. This month's cover story, by Fredericksburg writer
Bob Burke, outlines plans for a national slavery museum.
It is the dream of L. Douglas Wilder, an African-American
who defied many odds and became the first elected black
governor in the Old Dominion and the U.S. for that matter.
At least at its inception, the museum is a tremendously
worthy idea, since it would shine a spotlight on part
of Virginia's and America's past that badly needs telling.
The museum's exhibits could help demystify some of the
delusions that tend to be prevalent in this history-mad
state. To get a idea of what the white Virginia mindset
was during the 1920s and '30s, for instance, stop and
read any of those gray metal highway markers that dot
the state's country roads. They tend to be more whim
than fact and in some cases are downright racist.
Since then, there's been lots of progress towards historical
accuracy. Yet, as Cash points out, you simply can't
escape the fact that much of the South's history is
based on the brutal treatment of blacks by whites. A
good part of it also involves white Southerners trying
to mask guilt and create myths. Take Jim Crow laws.
White Southerners tried to justify them in the late
1800s by saying that they reflected the long-standing
dynamics between blacks and whites, when, in fact, they
were more recent creations to hasten back white control
after Reconstruction. Not that many decades ago, when
blacks weren't being lynched, they were being patronized
as Hattie McDaniel-style mammies.
Debunking the myth that blacks were well treated as
slaves, Cash writes: "The South's perpetual need
for justifying its career, and the will to shut away
more effectively the vision of its mounting hate and
brutality toward the black man, entered into the equation
also and bore these people yet further into the cult
of the Great Southern Heart. The Old South must be made
not only the happy country, but the happy country especially
for the negro. The lash? A lie, sir; it had never existed."
A national slave museum could do much to bring needed
perspective to the history of Virginia and the South.
As Bob's story points out, the museum could be cheapened
by McDonald's and Wal-Mart popping up nearby. And, with
such an emotionally loaded issue as slavery, it will
be interesting to see whose version of history prevails.
Hopefully, these issues will be resolved dispassionately.
Virginia would benefit immensely from the museum.
|
|